Can Arsenal really win the Champions League this season?

Arsenal's Champions League hopes are building momentum after last season's runners-up finish to PSG, but a word of caution has been raised over whether the Gunners are truly ready to go all the way this time.
In an opinion piece for JustArsenal, writer Liam Harding argued that despite the optimism surrounding Mikel Arteta's side, there remains a gap between Arsenal and Europe's genuine elite. “There's a lot of talk among Arsenal fans and in the media about us winning the Champions League this season. I think we can all agree that we'd love to see Mikel Arteta's side go one better than last season, when we finished runners-up to French giants PSG. But honestly, how realistic is that?” he wrote.
The Friday Injury Tracker
Who's out, who's back and what it means for the next two games.
The Fleetwood warning
Harding pointed to Arsenal's shock League Cup exit on penalties to League Two side Fleetwood Town as evidence of how quickly things can unravel. “Anything can happen in football, as we certainly know after bowing out of the League Cup on penalties to League Two Fleetwood Town. They hadn't even practised penalties before the game, and it was one of our worst displays in our entire history. If we get carried away in the Champions League, as perhaps we did in the League Cup, we could slip up once we get past the league phase, which we've started well,” he said.
He was quick to stress that this isn't about Arsenal adopting an underdog mentality, but rather a reality check given the club's recent European history. “I'm not saying we should go in feeling like underdogs. But if we came up against PSG in the final again, or even Bayern Munich, who we arguably struggled against already this season, we could find ourselves on the losing end again. We haven't established ourselves as one of the outright giants of the Champions League. We haven't won European silverware in over 30 years, which the likes of Bayern, PSG, Liverpool, Real Madrid and Chelsea can't relate to,” he wrote.
Looking back at last season's final
The piece also reflected on the semi final draw that paved Arsenal's path to last season's final, suggesting the route may have flattered the Gunners. “I do think we were lucky to draw Atlético Madrid in the semis last season, having already beaten them in the competition. It was a tighter contest that time, but I don't think we'd have reached the final if we'd come up against PSG instead. I can see them making this season's final for a third time in a row,” Harding said.
On the final itself, which Arsenal lost on penalties after a 1-1 draw following extra time, he added: “We struggled against PSG in the 2025 semi-final, and although we looked stronger against them in last season's final, they still had us chasing shadows at times. They could've thrashed us in extra time, but we held out. We peaked too early when Kai Havertz gave us the lead inside the opening ten minutes, and it was 1-1 after extra time before we lost on penalties. For me, we didn't really look like European winners that night.”
He also referenced this season's narrow 2-1 win over Slavia Prague as further proof that Arsenal haven't yet hit top gear in Europe, despite a strong start to the league phase. The debate over whether Arsenal have truly closed the gap on the Champions League's established giants looks set to continue as the knockout stages approach.



