Henry compares Man United turmoil to Arsenal's 'toxic' post-Wenger years

November 4, 2026Jed Dogomeo

Thierry Henry has drawn a direct line between Manchester United's current crisis and the uncertain years Arsenal endured after Arsene Wenger's departure, arguing that patience, not panic, eventually turned things around in north London.

Speaking on CBS before Manchester United's Champions League clash with Roma, Henry addressed the pressure mounting on Michael Carrick, who had been under serious threat of the sack following a nine game winless run that left United 17th in the Premier League and 20th in Europe's top competition.

The Friday Injury Tracker

Who's out, who's back and what it means for the next two games.

“If you go back to the last years of Arsene Wenger, Unai Emery and the beginning of Mikel Arteta, it was a tiny bit toxic,” Henry said. “The fans were going amongst each other, asking who the coach should be, who should come and go, having a go at the owners. It's a bit like what's happening with United now. Surely, along the way, all the coaches they've had could have been the answer? Did they give enough time to that one, you don't know who it could have been? You have guys that are strict, not strict, experienced, not experienced, club legends... it didn't work.”

Henry continued, pointing specifically at how Arsenal stuck with Mikel Arteta through difficult patches that might otherwise have cost him his job elsewhere.

“You're telling me that none of those coaches could have turned it around? Were they given time to turn it around? Arteta at times didn't have great runs in the league; didn't finish where Arsenal are supposed to finish. They kept him. Now everyone is saying he's a great coach. If he didn't have the time to show that he was a good coach, we would have said that he was inexperienced, couldn't handle it and couldn't win.”

Carrick buys himself time with Roma comeback

United fell 2-0 down inside 18 minutes against an in form Roma side at Old Trafford before roaring back in the second half to win 3-2, a result that eases some of the pressure on Carrick heading into the weekend trip to face Aston Villa.

His position had reportedly been set for reassessment by United's hierarchy during the November international break, though it remains unclear what bearing Tuesday's win will have on those plans.

Arsenal's own rebuild as the reference point

Henry's comments frame Arsenal's trajectory under Arteta, which eventually produced a first top flight title in 22 years, as evidence that sustained backing through rocky periods can pay off. The Spaniard endured criticism during spells of inconsistent league form before the club's results, and patience from the board, turned the project around.

Whether United's hierarchy takes the same approach with Carrick remains to be seen, but Henry's remarks, made on CBS and reported by the Evening Standard, add a notable Arsenal voice to the ongoing debate over United's managerial stability.